Stupid Things People Say About Gays – Transgender People are Deluded and Don’t Exist

Stupid Things People Say About Gays – Transgender People are Deluded and Don’t Exist

December 11, 2009 Featured Stupid Things People Say About Gays 6

Stupid Things People Say About GaysFor those that may not be familiar with, essentially, it is an LGBT blog community which reports on issues relevant to our community.  The Bilerico Project has over 80 contributors/editors and alumni including some of the most respected names in the LGBT rights movement like, Donna Rose, Jillian T. Wise, David Badash, Joe Solomenese, Kip Williams, Kate Clinton and many, many more. Their list includes the L, the G, the B and the T and reads as a who’s who in the equality movement.  Many authors there are my friends, many have been guests on Closet Talk and I always value their opinions and ideas.

But being friends, colleagues, guests or on a “who’s who” list doesn’t make Bilerico right when it comes to a recent post by contributor, Ronald Gold.  I can certainly understand publishing a piece that turns out to have a factual inaccuracy or even one that expresses an unpopular opinion. However, Ronald Gold may have expressed the least informed, most unfounded opinion ever published in an LGBT forum by a supposed advocate for equality.

In the article recently published, Mr. Gold makes the claim that gender is solely biological, then leaps to the conclusion that such fact evidences that “transgender” does not exist. As if this ill-advised conclusion isn’t dangerous enough, Mr. Gold continues:

I would, however, get after the doctors – the psychiatrists who use a phony medical model to invent a disease that doesn’t exist, and the surgeons who use such spurious diagnoses to mutilate the bodies of the deluded.

Did you catch that?  Mr. Gold just stated that transgender people are “deluded” in a forum designed to support LGBT people.  Did the world go amiss or was not getting enough traffic to substantiate the cost of advertising on the site?

Unfortunately for Mr. Gold and the Bilerico Project, such marketing ploy (if it is one) or such ignorance (which it more likely is) reflects not only on Mr. Gold, but the entire Bilerico Project and its contributors.  Obviously, Donna Rose would disagree with Mr. Gold’s position as well as many other contributors, but rather than publish an apology, the editorial staff at Bilerico Project chose instead to post the following editor’s note at the beginning of the post (several hours after its publication):

All posts published on Bilerico Project do not reflect the opinions of nor any endorsement by the Editorial Team. Many Bilerico readers and contributors have found Ronald Gold’s op-ed offensive or needlessly coarse. The idea behind Bilerico Project is to encourage dialogue among different facets of the LGBT community that might normally never interact this intimately. We encourage all readers to continue responding to Mr. Gold in the same spirit his post was written – with positive intent while bluntly stating your own opinion and experiences.

While I’m ordinarily quick to defend fellow equality fighters, I would have hoped that the editorial staff would have recognized hate speech and chosen not to publish the article.  In no way was this article written with “positive intent.”  I have to say I’m very disappointed with the Bilerico Project for helping propogate lies and misinformation about transgender people – even if it was just a publicity stunt.

Now you get my editor’s note for this post.  The column, Stupid Things People Say About Gays (of which this post is part of) uses the term “Gay” inclusively.  It’s always been so and will always be so. and all of its contributors strive to be fully inclusive and leave no freak behind.  More Stupid Things People Say About Gays can be found here.

Be Sociable, Share!


6 Responses

  1. […] See the rest here: Stupid Things People Say About Gays – Transgender People are … […]

  2. Thank you, Jay, for being the supportive inclusive ally that you are. I'm honored to be called your friend.

  3. SistersTalk says:

    I agree with every word you spoke here.

  4. christophersays says:

    Very well said, baby. Anyone claiming to defend a right to equality would not write to perpetuate the hate and fear that is known all too well by our community…our ENTIRE community. And in response, bilerico should simply publicly apologize as the article is pulled from their site. Free speach, yes…but choose a different audience if you continue to further the division between the have and the have nots. This is NOT about protecting a specific group. This is about equality and justice for all.

  5. MauraHennessey says:

    Thanks…the article was beyond inaccurate, it was the sort of fact free screed that the Christian Right unleashes all of the time upon the LGBT. Unfortunately, now Mr Gold has martyr status and the "who let the T's(or B's or L's) in is starting to re-emerge.

  6. johndeand says:

    Thankfully, bilerico project fired mr. gold! i hope this type of article doesn't happen again on bilerico or anywhere else =(

Comments are closed.